Abundance isn’t about creating new tools (means). It’s about governance, distribution and improving human outcomes (ends). Stop asking about what’s the problem-solution, start asking what’s the unique value you bring to the collective.
People view money as scarcity and they call it progress when GDP increases. I call it progress when we put scarcity into coordination. When we don't have 10 startups doing the same thing, but one doing the best thing. The collective will produce things together, like Airbus that aligned markets with community, talent, and policy interests.
In the era of trying to stick an LLM into every throat bottleneck, we should perhaps remember that SAP's MOAT was integration in customer offices, not the CRM product itself. We have confused the production of stuff with the integration of these products across the units needed. And then, instead of working towards upgrading the product itself, we have a dozen other startups trying to compete with the behemoth that captures most of the market share, increasing (emotional) competition, and making the value for the end user drop.
We should also remember that AI leaders not only don't have the trust of society, they also don't have the trust of developers. Stripe grew because of developers. Stripe had an exceptional support team. Their job was to make digital financial transactions very abstract so that the average developer can easily use their SDKs. And all of that ecosystem and support eventually attracted developers to the point that when AWS wanted to switch to Amazon Pay, developers hesitated because they would lose the advantages and user experience that came from using Stripe systems and packages. The issue is that we have more mathematicians, physicists and theoretical computer scientists, training and optimizing the AI models, than we have programmers optimizing for stability and usefulness, who live inside production systems.
According to political economy, technology increases productive capacity. Yet abundance depends on incentives, institutions, coordination, norms, and distribution mechanisms. The common example with the fact that we produce enough food globally, yet hunger exists. That’s not a production failure. It’s a distribution and governance failure. And the people trying to solve it not only can’t get structurally rewarded through markets, but their ventures barely survive to develop adequate coordination solutions. It’s important to remember that technology can create potential abundance, yet governance determines realized abundance. A bank could try setting up a SEZ to experiment with decentralized currencies, but why doesn’t it try to regulate the future first (like Rockefeller did when Standard Oil was split), instead of letting others disrupt its incumbent?
We all know that VCs rather prefer to talk about potential instead of substance. If we live in abundance, why do we rush, when our fundamentals as humans to flourish are being covered (e.g. food, housing)? Capital is eating the world. Maybe that is the game Europeans have understood over centuries. Become a polymath, a holistic person, while not rushing. Speed isn't a trait we have to tribute. Continuity, as Stewart Brand puts it. For example, it has long been verified that the tools (apps, infinite content, zero friction dopamine) are outpacing the human nervous system's capacity to regulate. A racecar engine (tools) without good brakes (integration and coordination), crashes constantly.
Silicon Valley can tell you, we have blockchain and we have NFTs, and we can tell you whether an image or information is authentic. But they cannot tell you whether this information that goes through the blockchain is actually real or fake news. The issue was never that we didn't have the technology of blockchain. The issue is that we never had a good way of verifying that this information here is legitimate. Silicon Valley has always focused on tool creation and the belief that if you create a powerful enough tool, the world will reorganize itself around it. Institutions however, require legitimacy, which is a social construct, not a technical one. Nevertheless, progress requires emotional regulation, not logic.
So let me ask you, do you believe science is evolving faster nowadays? What if it hasn’t? Sure, we have made tremendous jumps in theory. But this is another case where we have expanded the map perfectly, and left the territory uncharted? Decades after Peter Thiel said about flying cars, we still don't have them. 3D Printed aesthetic homes? ICON is still trying because financially it doesn't make sense to them, or because they focused on reducing home prices through technology first, instead of premium aesthetic 3D-printed houses. Maybe we are just missing the pill.